Is this game notation correct?

[Volker Pittlik]

While trying to find incorrect moves I found this game. I think the result is incorrect:

Code: Select all

[Event "Tatatovaros"]
[Site "Tatatovaros"]
[Date "1935.07.20"]
[Round "14"]
[White "Kluger, Gyula"]
[Black "Szabo, Laszlo"]
[Result "0-1"]
[ECO "C13p"]
[EventDate "1935.07.07"]
[Annotator "Scorpio"]

1.e4 e6 2.d4 d5 3.Nc3 Nf6 4.Bg5 Be7 5.e5 Nfd7 6.h4 c5 7.Nb5 f6 8.Bd3 a6 9.
Nd6+
    { Move out of book ( Qh5+ 100%)}
9...Bxd6 10.exd6 cxd4 11.Qh5+ Kf8 12.Nf3 Nc6 13.O-O-O Qe8 14.Qg4 e5 15.Qg3
Nc5 16.h5 Nxd3+ 17.Rxd3 h6 18.Bxf6 gxf6 19.Nh4 Kf7 20.Re1 Ke6 21.Ng6 Kxd6
22.Rf3 Rf8 23.Nxf8 Qxf8 24.Qg6 Ke7 25.Qh7+ Qf7 26.Qxh6 Be6 27.Rg3 Rg8 28.
Rb3 Bc8 29.g3 Rg5 30.Qh8 Qg8 31.Qh6 Qg7 32.Qxg7+ Rxg7 33.Rh1 e4 34.Rb6 Kd6
35.a4 Kc7 36.a5 Bg4 37.h6 Rh7 38.Kd2 Bf3 39.Rh4 Kd6 40.b3 Kc7 41.Rh3 Bg4
42.Rh1 f5 43.Rh4 Kd6 44.Rh1 Kc5 45.Rh4 Ne5 46.Rh1 Nf3+ 47.Ke2 Ng5+ 48.Kd2
$201 e3+ $4 $18
    { Scorpio: Analysis reports blunder, with score change from/to:  -3.97
    / +5.54}
    ( 48...Nf3+ 49.Kc1 e3 50.Kd1 Nd2+ 51.Ke1 Ne4 52.fxe3 dxe3 53.Rg6 Nxg3
    54.Rg7 Rh8 55.Rh2 Ne4 56.Rxb7 $19 )
49.Kd3 Be2+ 50.Kxe2 Ne4 51.fxe3 dxe3 52.Kxe3 Nxg3 53.Rh4 d4+ 54.Kf4 0-1


When Scorpio found the dubious move white has clear advantage. Some moves later the programs display a mate sore:

[diag]8/1p5r/pR5P/P1k2p2/3p3R/1P2K1n1/2P5/8 w - - 0 54[/diag]

8/1p5r/pR5P/P1k2p2/3p3R/1P2K1n1/2P5/8 w - - 0 54

I didn't see it but the programs agree ( { 100:+327.00} 54.Rxd4 Re7+ 55.Kd3 Re3+ 56.Kxe3 Nf1+ 57.Kd3 Nd2 58. b4# ).

One move later black wins. Does someone know something about this game? Is the pgn correct? Maybe white lost for other reasons?


Volker

[Kurt Utzinger]

Hi Volker
I have found the game you posted at
http://www.chessgames.com/perl/chessgame?gid=1004420
but it's the same (perhaps wrong) notation.
Regards
Kurt

[Volker Pittlik]

...
but it's the same (perhaps wrong) notation.
Regards
Kurt[/b]

Thanks. I guess we have simply to accept that PGN is really often wrong.

Regards

Volker