Page 1 of 1

Why not combione SmallTalk and General?

PostPosted: 27 Sep 2004, 13:18
by Joachim Rang
Hi Volker,

as some already mentioned in the old board too many sections are confusing. I think with the current density of posts 4 sections are enough, so I'd combine General and SmallTalk since I fail to see the need to differentiate between these things. What do you and others think?

regards Joachim

Re: Why not combione SmallTalk and General?

PostPosted: 27 Sep 2004, 13:27
by Anonymous
I agree with you.

Re: Why not combione SmallTalk and General?

PostPosted: 27 Sep 2004, 13:50
by Volker Pittlik
Joachim Rang wrote:Hi Volker,

as some already mentioned in the old board too many sections are confusing. I think with the current density of posts 4 sections are enough, so I'd combine General and SmallTalk since I fail to see the need to differentiate between these things. What do you and others think?

regards Joachim


I do not deny to make changes but maybe we should wait some days until there are more messages.

Possibly I'm going to change the name of the "General" forum to "Winboard/Xboard" because it is the core of this whole board. I wouldn't like to mix that with other topics.

Maybe a combination of "Related Software" and "Smalltalk" is a better solution.

Regards

Volker

Re: Why not combione SmallTalk and General?

PostPosted: 28 Sep 2004, 02:20
by Guest
Posting by subject types "software-general- tournys etc".
Is good idea due to the large number of posts that are made, a method to index is very good idea..

One man's thoughts on it.

There is no Smalltalk here!

PostPosted: 05 Oct 2004, 08:08
by Greg Simpson
I was surprised to see a Smalltalk section in the new forum, since most engines seem to be written in C or Delfi. Looking around, you seem to have meant small talk instead. It is really quite wrong to combine "small" and "talk" into one word if you mean casual discussion and not the computer language. If you don't combine the sections, perhaps you could rename this one?

I have enjoyed lurking around the Winboard Form for the last couple of months, and I thank Volker for making it available.

Re: There is no Smalltalk here!

PostPosted: 05 Oct 2004, 08:27
by F.Huber
Hi Greg,

GregSimpson wrote:It is really quite wrong to combine "small" and "talk" into one word if you mean casual discussion ...


isn?t it also really quite wrong to combine "Greg" and "Simpson" to one word? :wink:

Ok, just a joke of course, :lol:
welcome to the forum,
Franz.

Re: Why not combione SmallTalk and General?

PostPosted: 05 Oct 2004, 10:40
by Peter Fendrich
Volker Pittlik wrote:
Joachim Rang wrote:Hi Volker,

Maybe a combination of "Related Software" and "Smalltalk" is a better solution.

Regards

Volker


I still think that you should remove Smalltalk completely.
Smalltalk will appear hear and there and it is no big deal to miss it.

Better rename "general" to "Winboard" as you suggested and also include "Related Software" in that.

Voila - one forum is gone!

Re: Why not combine SmallTalk and General?

PostPosted: 05 Oct 2004, 11:04
by Volker Pittlik
Peter Fendrich wrote:...
I still think that you should remove Smalltalk completely.
Smalltalk will appear hear and there and it is no big deal to miss it.

Better rename "general" to "Winboard" as you suggested and also include "Related Software" in that.

Voila - one forum is gone!


OK, maybe you are right. I'm going to create a poll soon.

Regards

Volker