Pro Deo 1.0 vs. All (a little test)

[Miroslav Nikolic]

Geschrieben von:/Posted by: Miroslav Nikolic at 02 October 2004 15:22:37:





ProDeo vs All
PIII 800MHz 256MB
Windows XP SP1
GUI: Winboard 4.2.7
TM: GalisWBTM 0.5
Time: 60min/game
Cycles: 8
Book: own
Nalimov tb: yes
Hash table: 32MB
Pondering: off

Participants:

Engine Author (Country)
------------------------------------------------------------
Pro Deo 1.0 Ed Schroeder (Netherlands)
Aristarch 4.50 Stefan Zipproth (Germany)
Crafty 19.17 Robert Hyatt (USA)
Delfi 4.5 Fabio Cavicchio (Italy)
AnMon 5.40 Christian Barreteau (France)
Amyan 1.594 Antonio Dieguez (Chile)
Ktulu 4.2 Rahman Paidar (Iran)
Thinker 4.6c Lance Perkins (Canada)
Green Light Chess 3.034 Tim Foden (GBR)
Pharaon 2.62 Franck Zibi (France)
Yace 0.99.87 Dieter Bürßner (Germany)
Ruffian 1.0.5 Per Ola Valfridsson (Sweden)

Crosstable:
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Rank Engine Games Wins Draws Points Score %
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
0. Pro Deo 1.0 88 43 20 54,0 60,22

1. Delfi 4.5 8 5 0 5,0 62,50
1. Pharaon 2.62 8 5 0 5,0 62,50
2. Ruffian 1.0.5 8 3 2 4,0 50,00
3. Ktulu 4.2 8 2 3 3,5 43,75
3. Aristarch 4.50 8 2 3 3,5 43,75
4. Amyan 1.594 8 2 2 3,0 37,50
5. Thinker 4.6c 8 1 3 2,5 31,25
5. Green Light Chess 3.034 8 1 3 2,5 31,25
5. Crafty 19.17 8 2 1 2,5 31,25
5. AnMon 5.40 8 2 1 2,5 31,25
6. Yace 0.99.87 8 0 2 1,0 12,50

Results:
Pro Deo 1.0 - Aristarch 4.50 4,5:3,5
Pro Deo 1.0 - Crafty 19.17 5,5:2,5
Pro Deo 1.0 - Delfi 4.5 3,0:5,0 (!)
Pro Deo 1.0 - AnMon 5.40 5,5:2,5
Pro Deo 1.0 - Amyan 1.594 5,0:3,0
Pro Deo 1.0 - Ktulu 4.2 4,5:3,5
Pro Deo 1.0 - Thinker 4.6c 5,5:2,5
Pro Deo 1.0 - Green Light Chess 3.034 5,5:2,5
Pro Deo 1.0 - Pharaon 2.62 3,0:5,0 (!)
Pro Deo 1.0 - Yace 0.99.87 7,0:1,0 (!)
Pro Deo 1.0 - Ruffian 1.0.5 4,0:4,0

Pro Deo 1.0 (white): 29:12 (+26, =06, -12) (!)
Pro Deo 1.0 (black): 24:20 (+17, =14, -13) (!)
Pro Deo 1.0 (all): 54:34 (+43, =20, -25)

To my regret, I have not own web site. Pgn games per e-mail.

Best wishes,
Miroslav

[Roger Brown]

Geschrieben von:/Posted by: Roger Brown at 02 October 2004 16:00:41:
Als Antwort auf:/In reply to: Pro Deo 1.0 vs. All (a little test) geschrieben von:/posted by: Miroslav Nikolic at 02 October 2004 15:22:37:

Hello Miroslav,
Did you use the latest settings from Ed (September 2004)?
Thanks for more data....
Later.

[Miroslav Nikolic]

Geschrieben von:/Posted by: Miroslav Nikolic at 02 October 2004 17:25:48:
Als Antwort auf:/In reply to: Re: Pro Deo 1.0 vs. All (a little test) geschrieben von:/posted by: Roger Brown at 02 October 2004 16:00:41:

Hello Miroslav,
Did you use the latest settings from Ed (September 2004)?
Thanks for more data....
Later.

Hello Roger,
In Winboard GUI significant is INI file (not ENG)?
My "Rebel.ini" was:
[Analyze Game]
Analyze Game = Normal * Normal | Fixed Depth | ENG-ENG | AUTO232
Analyze Margin = 0.25 * 0.10|0.15|0.20|0.25|0.30|0.30|0.40|0.50
[Book Learning]
Show learned value = OFF * OFF | ON
Show original value = OFF * OFF | ON
Show learning depth = OFF * OFF | ON
Book Learner = Aggressive * OFF | Passive | Moderate | Strong | Aggressive
Book Learner Expiration = Two week * OFF | Two weeks | One week | One day | Always
Extended Book Learner = OFF * OFF | READ | WRITE | READ&WRITE
[Position Learning]
Position Learner = ON * OFF | ON
Engine Learner = OFF * OFF | ON
Engine Expiration = CLEAR * OFF | ON | CLEAR
[Analyze Game]
Analyze Game = Normal * Normal | Fixed Depth | ENG-ENG | AUTO232
Analyze Margin = 0.25 * 0.10|0.15|0.20|0.25|0.30|0.30|0.40|0.50
Thanks,
Miroslav

[Roger Brown]

Geschrieben von:/Posted by: Roger Brown at 02 October 2004 23:43:50:
Als Antwort auf:/In reply to: Re: Pro Deo 1.0 vs. All (a little test) geschrieben von:/posted by: Miroslav Nikolic at 02 October 2004 17:25:48:

Hello Roger,
In Winboard GUI significant is INI file (not ENG)?

Hello Miroslav,
When ProDeo loads in any gui it selects a personality. Param.txt gives the information as seen below.

Executable made on 01-08-2004
Personality Path personal/REBEL.ENG (0)
Personality description Default engine (August 11, 2004)

As you can see, the personality here is the default one.
The Rebel.eng is important. Not that your results are invalidated. I just wanted to know which personality ProDeo was using.
Later.

[Miroslav Nikolic]

Geschrieben von:/Posted by: Miroslav Nikolic at 03 October 2004 00:41:24:
Als Antwort auf:/In reply to: Re: Pro Deo 1.0 vs. All (a little test) geschrieben von:/posted by: Roger Brown at 02 October 2004 23:43:50:

Hello Roger,
In Winboard GUI significant is INI file (not ENG)?

Hello Miroslav,
When ProDeo loads in any gui it selects a personality. Param.txt gives the information as seen below.

Executable made on 01-08-2004
Personality Path personal/REBEL.ENG (0)
Personality description Default engine (August 11, 2004)

As you can see, the personality here is the default one.
The Rebel.eng is important. Not that your results are invalidated. I just wanted to know which personality ProDeo was using.
Later.

Hello Roger,
Thanks for this Information. Date of Rebel.eng is 3. Septembar 2004.
Regards,
Miroslav