I think the problem with the wrong mate scores when losing is fixed, do you see this problem in 0.4 ?
Oh, I have just played a single game yet with new Diablo.
I did not assume that you would have fixed it, because I
guessed it is perhaps quite low on your priority list
I'm not familiar with the random 0 scores. I usually test under Arena and don't see it, what is your setup? Windboard with polyglot? If you see it perhaps you could send me the positions where it appears.
I will send you logs and debugs. I canb just add that Gothmog/Glaurung
long had the same problem, but IIRC Tord finally corrected it in later
versions. (Some other programs do this too BTW, also score reversing)
A few examples from recent Class D:
1: moves 67, 68
2: moves 26, 30
3: moves 65-67, 74
2 snippets from logs for move 65 example 3
(first snippet WB debug, second part of the bigger full
UCI log received by Polyglot)- Code: Select all
2470272 >first : time 43897
otim 70203
2470272 >first : g8g7
2470282 <second: kibitz -946(9) 9403311 nds 894001 nps 10515 ms 161880 evs
2470342 <first : 2 +991 0 399 Rf4 Bg4
2470342 <first : 3 +991 0 629 Rf4 Bh7
2470342 <first : 4 +991 0 996 Rf4 Bh7
2470342 <first : 5 +991 0 1404 Rf4 Bh7
2470342 <first : 6 +991 0 1706 Rf4 Bh7
2470342 <first : 7 +991 0 1938 Rf4 Bh7
2470342 <first : 8 +991 0 2172 Rf4 Bh7
2470342 <first : 9 +991 0 2668 Rf4 Bh7
2470342 <first : 10 +991 0 3165 Rf4 Bh7
2470342 <first : 11 +991 0 3568 Rf4 Bh7
2470342 <first : 12 +991 1 4080 Rf4 Bh7
2470342 <first : 13 +991 1 5620 Rf4 Bh7
2470583 <first : 14 +991 24 143125 Rf4 Bh7
2479756 <first : 15 +1091 943 6250150 Rf4 Bh7
2492244 <first : 15 +0 2195 10555392 Rf4 Bh7
2492244 <first : 16 +0 2195 10555393 Rf4 Bh7
2492244 <first : 16 +0 2195 10555393 Rf4 Bh7
2492244 <first : move h4f4
- Code: Select all
> ENGINE go wtime 438970 btime 702030 movestogo 16
< ENGINE got 16 from line 16
< ENGINE info depth 2 score cp 991 time 0 nodes 399 pv h4f4 f5g4
> XBOARD 2 +991 0 399 Rf4 Bg4
< ENGINE info depth 3 score cp 991 time 0 nodes 629 pv h4f4 f5h7 e5d7
> XBOARD 3 +991 0 629 Rf4 Bh7
< ENGINE info depth 4 score cp 991 time 0 nodes 996 pv h4f4 f5h7 e5d7 d8d7
> XBOARD 4 +991 0 996 Rf4 Bh7
< ENGINE info depth 5 score cp 991 time 0 nodes 1404 pv h4f4 f5h7 e5d7 d8d7
> XBOARD 5 +991 0 1404 Rf4 Bh7
< ENGINE info depth 6 score cp 991 time 0 nodes 1706 pv h4f4 f5h7 e5d7 d8d7
> XBOARD 6 +991 0 1706 Rf4 Bh7
< ENGINE info depth 7 score cp 991 time 0 nodes 1938 pv h4f4 f5h7 e5d7 d8d7
> XBOARD 7 +991 0 1938 Rf4 Bh7
< ENGINE info depth 8 score cp 991 time 0 nodes 2172 pv h4f4 f5h7 e5d7 d8d7
> XBOARD 8 +991 0 2172 Rf4 Bh7
< ENGINE info depth 9 score cp 991 time 0 nodes 2668 pv h4f4 f5h7 e5d7 d8d7
> XBOARD 9 +991 0 2668 Rf4 Bh7
< ENGINE info depth 10 score cp 991 time 0 nodes 3165 pv h4f4 f5h7 e5d7 d8d7
> XBOARD 10 +991 0 3165 Rf4 Bh7
< ENGINE info depth 11 score cp 991 time 0 nodes 3568 pv h4f4 f5h7 e5d7 d8d7
> XBOARD 11 +991 0 3568 Rf4 Bh7
< ENGINE info depth 12 score cp 991 time 10 nodes 4080 pv h4f4 f5h7 e5d7 d8d7
> XBOARD 12 +991 1 4080 Rf4 Bh7
< ENGINE info depth 13 score cp 991 time 10 nodes 5620 pv h4f4 f5h7 e5d7 d8d7
> XBOARD 13 +991 1 5620 Rf4 Bh7
< ENGINE info depth 14 score cp 991 time 241 nodes 143125 pv h4f4 f5h7 e5d7 d8d7
> XBOARD 14 +991 24 143125 Rf4 Bh7
< ENGINE info depth 15 score cp 1091 time 9434 nodes 6250150 pv h4f4 f5h7 e5d7 d8d7
> XBOARD 15 +1091 943 6250150 Rf4 Bh7
< ENGINE info depth 15 score mate 0 time 21952 nodes 10555392 pv h4f4 f5h7 e5d7 d8d7
> XBOARD 15 +0 2195 10555392 Rf4 Bh7
< ENGINE info depth 16 score mate 0 time 21952 nodes 10555393 pv h4f4 f5h7 e5d7 d8d7
> XBOARD 16 +0 2195 10555393 Rf4 Bh7
< ENGINE bestmove h4f4 ponder f5h7
> XBOARD 16 +0 2195 10555393 Rf4 Bh7
> XBOARD move h4f4
POLYGLOT MOVE Rf4
[Event "RWBC_Class_D_6th_Edition"]
[Site "ESPRESSO"]
[Date "2005.11.29"]
[Round "1"]
[Number "12"]
[White "DrunkenMaster_12"]
[Black "Diablo_03"]
[Result "0-1"]
[TimeControl "40/900"]
1. e4 {+0.00/1} c5 2. Nf3 {+0.00/1} d6 3. d4 {+0.00/1} cxd4 4.
Nxd4 {+0.00/1} Nf6 5. Nc3 {+0.00/1} a6 6. Be3 {+0.00/1} e6 7. Be2 {+0.00/1}
Be7 8. O-O {+0.66/9} O-O {-0.51/11} 9. a4 {+0.00/1} d5 {-0.38/12} 10.
exd5 {+0.51/10} exd5 {-0.36/12} 11. Qd3 {+0.56/9} Re8 {-0.24/10} 12.
Nf5 {+0.55/8} Bb4 {-0.02/11} 13. Na2 {+0.41/8} Ba5 {+0.03/11} 14.
b4 {+0.26/8} Bc7 {+0.21/11} 15. Ng3 {+0.11/8} Nc6 {+0.26/10} 16.
Bg5 {-0.06/8} Be5 {+0.32/10} 17. c3 {+0.02/9} h6 {+0.31/10} 18.
Bd2 {-0.07/8} Ne4 {+0.46/10} 19. Be3 {-0.23/8} Nxc3 {+0.49/11} 20.
Nxc3 {-0.45/10} d4 {+0.58/11} 21. b5 {-0.45/8} dxe3 {+0.59/11} 22.
Qxe3 {-0.59/9} Bd4 {+0.64/11} 23. Qc1 {-0.58/10} axb5 {+0.51/11} 24.
axb5 {-0.52/10} Rxa1 {+0.47/10} 25. Qxa1 {-0.53/10} Ne5 {+0.43/10} 26.
Qa3 {-0.51/9} b6 {+0.42/10} 27. Kh1 {-0.59/9} Qh4 {+0.71/11} 28.
Nce4 {-0.73/8} Rd8 {+0.59/10} 29. Qb4 {-0.71/9} Ng4 {+0.59/12} 30.
Bxg4 {-0.64/10} Bxg4 {+0.54/13} 31. f3 {-0.57/11} Be6 {+0.59/12} 32.
f4 {-0.52/10} Be3 {+0.96/12} 33. f5 {-0.64/9} Bd5 {+0.98/12} 34.
f6 {-0.78/10} Re8 {+1.33/13} 35. Nf5 {-1.06/11} Rxe4 {+1.33/14} 36.
Qd6 {-1.54/11} Qxf6 {+1.32/13} 37. Qxd5 {-1.58/11} Rf4 {+1.33/14} 38.
Qd3 {-1.56/12} Rxf1+ {+1.30/13} 39. Qxf1 {-1.53/13} Bc5 {+1.32/15} 40.
Ng3 {-1.42/12} Qxf1+ {+1.33/15} 41. Nxf1 {-1.35/17} Kf8 {+1.44/17} 42.
Ng3 {-1.58/17} Ke7 {+1.72/18} 43. Nf5+ {-1.63/16} Kf6 {+1.94/20} 44.
g4 {-2.01/17} g6 {+1.94/19} 45. Nh4 {-1.91/17} Ke5 {+1.95/18} 46.
Kg2 {-1.94/17} Kd5 {+1.98/18} 47. Nf3 {-1.90/17} Bd6 {+2.05/17} 48.
Kf2 {-1.85/16} Kc4 {+2.17/16} 49. Ke3 {-2.09/15} Kxb5 {+2.14/16} 50.
Kd4 {-2.11/15} Kc6 {+2.25/16} 51. h4 {-2.08/15} b5 {+2.12/15} 52.
h5 {-2.12/14} gxh5 {+2.09/14} 53. gxh5 {-2.05/15} Bc5+ {+2.36/17} 54.
Ke4 {-2.07/15} b4 {+2.55/17} 55. Kd3 {-2.45/16} Kb5 {+2.68/18} 56.
Kc2 {-2.47/17} Ka4 {+2.70/19} 57. Nh4 {-2.47/17} Be3 {+2.84/19} 58.
Nf5 {-2.47/18} b3+ {+2.81/22} 59. Kb2 {-2.48/21} Bf4 {+2.81/24} 60.
Ne7 {-2.48/20} Be5+ {+2.81/23} 61. Kb1 {-2.46/21} Bd6 {+2.81/23} 62.
Nf5 {-2.45/21} Bf4 {+2.81/24} 63. Ne7 {-2.44/22} Kb5 {+2.81/24} 64.
Kb2 {-2.44/21} Kc4 {+2.81/23} 65. Nf5 {-2.44/20} Kb4 {+2.81/22} 66.
Ka1 {-2.44/19} Kc3 {+2.81/23} 67. Kb1 {-2.39/20} Kc4 {+0.00/22} 68.
Kb2 {+0.00/24} f6 {+2.60/20} 69. Ne7 {-2.38/19} Be5+ {+3.53/20} 70.
Kb1 {-327.67/19} Kd3 {+4.03/22} 71. Nc6 {-3.17/18} Bd4 {+4.03/20} 72.
Ne7 {-327.67/19} Ke4 {+4.61/21} 73. Ng8 {-327.67/18} f5 {+0.00/21} 74.
Nxh6 {-327.67/17}
{White Resigns} 0-1
[Event "RWBC_Class_D_6th_Edition"]
[Site "ESPRESSO"]
[Date "2005.12.01"]
[Round "3"]
[Number "49"]
[White "Chiron_041"]
[Black "Diablo_03"]
[Result "1-0"]
[TimeControl "40/900"]
1. e4 c5 2. Nf3 e6 3. d4 cxd4 4. Nxd4 a6 5. c4 Nf6 6. Nc3 Qc7 7. a3 b6 8.
f4 {+1.24/9} Bb7 {-0.32/11} 9. e5 {+0.56/11} Ne4 {-0.15/12} 10.
Nxe4 {+0.29/11} Bxe4 {-0.23/11} 11. Bd3 {+0.23/10} Bxg2 {+0.50/12} 12.
Rg1 {+0.15/11} Bb7 {+0.49/11} 13. Be3 {-0.20/10} g6 {+0.63/10} 14.
Nf3 {-0.35/9} Bc5 {+0.64/10} 15. Qe2 {-0.53/10} Bxe3 {+0.64/11} 16.
Qxe3 {-0.31/11} Bxf3 {+0.64/11} 17. Qxf3 {-0.37/12} Nc6 {+0.59/11} 18.
O-O-O {-0.34/11} Rc8 {+0.71/11} 19. Kb1 {-0.37/10} O-O {+0.69/11} 20.
h4 {-0.41/10} Na5 {+0.64/11} 21. Ka2 {-0.52/10} Rfd8 {+0.70/10} 22.
Rc1 {-0.87/10} Nc6 {+0.88/11} 23. h5 {+0.34/10} Kf8 {+0.47/11} 24.
hxg6 {+0.97/11} hxg6 {-0.70/12} 25. Bxg6 {+1.52/10} fxg6 {-0.99/11} 26.
Rxg6 {+5.98/10} d6 {+0.00/12} 27. Rf6+ {+7.45/10} Ke7 {-5.47/12} 28.
Qh3 {+7.73/9} Re8 {-5.69/11} 29. Rxe6+ {+8.19/10} Kd8 {-5.97/12} 30.
Rxd6+ {+9.08/10} Qxd6 {+0.00/14} 31. exd6 {+11.62/11} Rf8 {-8.82/12} 32.
Rg1 {+12.16/10} Ra8 {-15.77/13} 33. Qh6 {+327.40/10} Re8 {-99.85/11} 34.
Qf6+ {+327.42/9} Kc8 {-99.87/11} 35. Rg7 {+327.48/9} Rd8 {-99.89/11} 36.
Qe6+ {+327.56/9} Kb8 {-99.91/13} 37. Rb7+ {+327.58/10} Kxb7 {-99.91/3} 38.
Qf7+ {+327.60/10} Ne7 {-99.91/11} 39. Qxe7+ {+327.59/9} Rd7 {-99.97/15} 40.
Qxd7+ {+327.64/9} Kb8 {-99.97/3} 41. Qc7# {+327.66/2}
{White mates} 1-0
[Event "RWBC_Class_D_6th_Edition"]
[Site "ESPRESSO"]
[Date "2005.12.08"]
[Round "5"]
[Number "106"]
[White "Diablo_03"]
[Black "OliThink_411"]
[Result "1-0"]
[TimeControl "40/900"]
[Annotator "7. -0.01 9... -0.45"]
1. d4 Nf6 2. c4 e6 3. Nc3 d5 4. cxd5 exd5 5. Bg5 c6 6. e3 h6 7.
Bh4 {-0.01/11} Be7 8. Bd3 {+0.09/11} O-O 9. Nf3 {+0.17/10} Ne4 {-0.45/8}
10. Bxe7 {+0.25/12} Qxe7 {-0.26/11} 11. Qc2 {+0.29/12} Bf5 {-0.18/11} 12.
Bxe4 {+0.16/12} dxe4 {+0.09/11} 13. Nd2 {-0.10/10} Re8 {-0.04/10} 14.
Qb3 {-0.17/10} Be6 {+0.23/10} 15. Qc2 {+0.00/12} f5 {+0.45/11} 16.
O-O {-0.09/10} Nd7 {+0.37/10} 17. Ne2 {+0.01/10} Bf7 {+0.48/10} 18.
Rac1 {+0.03/10} a5 {+0.61/9} 19. Rfd1 {+0.08/10} a4 {+0.74/9} 20.
Qb1 {+0.04/10} Kh8 {+0.75/9} 21. Nc4 {+0.07/10} b5 {+0.73/10} 22.
Na3 {+0.03/11} Qd6 {+0.77/9} 23. Nf4 {+0.02/11} g5 {+0.83/10} 24.
Ne2 {+0.08/11} Nb6 {+0.91/10} 25. Qc2 {+0.13/12} Nc4 {+0.84/10} 26.
Ng3 {+0.09/12} Qf8 {+0.89/10} 27. Nxc4 {+0.11/12} Bxc4 {+0.84/10} 28.
Re1 {+0.12/11} Bxa2 {+0.90/9} 29. Qxc6 {+0.75/13} Bc4 {+0.74/10} 30.
Qg6 {+0.25/12} f4 {+0.83/10} 31. exf4 {+0.85/13} Re6 {+0.54/11} 32.
Qh5 {+0.97/12} Qxf4 {+0.42/10} 33. Nxe4 {+0.89/12} Rd8 {+0.50/9} 34.
g3 {+0.94/12} Qf5 {+0.42/10} 35. Nc5 {+0.82/12} Rf6 {+0.41/9} 36.
Re8+ {+0.88/11} Rxe8 {+0.33/9} 37. Qxe8+ {+0.85/12} Kh7 {+0.25/9} 38.
Qe4 {+0.79/12} Bd5 {+0.44/10} 39. Qxf5+ {+1.00/14} Rxf5 {+0.13/9} 40.
Nd7 {+1.00/13} Rf7 {+0.09/9} 41. Ne5 {+1.38/12} Rb7 {-0.21/11} 42.
Rc5 {+1.31/13} Bb3 {-0.39/11} 43. Nc6 {+1.22/12} Rb6 {-0.20/10} 44.
f4 {+1.01/11} gxf4 {+0.20/11} 45. gxf4 {+0.89/13} Kg7 {+0.03/11} 46.
Kf2 {+1.09/12} b4 {-0.06/10} 47. Ne5 {+0.97/12} Rb7 {-0.17/10} 48.
d5 {+1.09/11} a3 {-0.08/10} 49. bxa3 {+1.11/13} bxa3 {-0.16/10} 50.
Ra5 {+1.11/12} a2 {-0.31/10} 51. d6 {+1.11/13} Bd5 {-0.34/9} 52.
d7 {+1.29/12} Rb8 {-0.47/9} 53. Ke3 {+1.24/12} Rd8 {-0.68/8} 54.
f5 {+1.38/13} Kf6 {-0.80/9} 55. Kd4 {+1.50/14} Bb3 {-0.96/9} 56.
Ke4 {+1.59/13} Kg7 {-1.16/9} 57. Ra6 {+1.81/13} Kh7 {-1.25/9} 58.
Kd4 {+3.24/13} h5 {-2.48/9} 59. Kc5 {+3.82/13} Bc2 {-3.23/8} 60.
f6 {+5.08/14} Be4 {-3.67/8} 61. Rxa2 {+7.14/13} h4 {-5.80/9} 62.
Ra4 {+9.68/14} Bf5 {-7.92/10} 63. Rxh4+ {+9.83/15} Kg8 64. f7+ {+9.91/15}
Kg7 {-9.46/9} 65. Rf4 {+0.00/16} Rxd7 {-9.80/10} 66. Nxd7 {+0.00/13}
Kxf7 {-10.02/10} 67. Rxf5+ {+0.00/13} Ke6 {-10.43/9} 68. Re5+ {+99.87/14}
Kf7 {-10.40/9} 69. Kd6 {+99.91/12} Kg6 {-324.90/10} 70. Ke6 {+99.93/12}
Kg7 {-324.92/10} 71. Rg5+ {+99.95/13} Kh7 {-324.94/9} 72. Kf7 {+99.97/13}
Kh6 {-324.96/10} 73. Re5 {+99.99/13} Kh7 74. Rh5# {+0.00/13}
{White mates} 1-0
Thanks for the comments Gunther.
Thanks for Diablo, Marcus and congrats BTW for the promotion
to Class C in RWBC.
Best wishes,
Guenther